Date of Award

Fall 2026

Access Type

Dissertation - Open Access

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy in Aviation

Department

College of Aviation

Committee Chair

Scott R. Winter

Committee Chair Email

[email protected]

First Committee Member

Stephen Rice

First Committee Member Email

[email protected]

Second Committee Member

David S. Cross

Second Committee Member Email

[email protected]

Third Committee Member

Gajapriya Tamilselvan

Third Committee Member Email

[email protected]

College Dean

Alan J. Stolzer

Abstract

The aviation industry has experienced a growing number of disruptive passenger incidents in recent years. Among the most prevalent forms of disruptive behavior is passenger noncompliance with cabin crew instructions. Failure to follow cabin crew instructions during safety-critical situations can endanger the safety of the aircraft, flight crew, cabin crew, and passengers, potentially resulting in fatal consequences. Ensuring passenger adherence to safety protocols could be particularly challenging in environments where perceptions of gender roles and competence may shape attitudinal or behavioral responses, as well as the safety incident severity context shaping decision making.

Through the lens of social role theory this study investigated whether cabin crew gender, passenger gender, and safety incident severity influence passenger willingness to comply with cabin crew safety instructions. A quantitative factorial survey experiment was conducted using a convenience sample of 341 highly rated, experienced users of the online research platform Prolific®. Participants self-reported their gender, which served as the measure of passenger gender. Participants were then randomly assigned to a cabin crew gender condition. Participants completed the modified and validated scales measuring the proposed mediators before indicating their willingness to comply with cabin crew instructions across four safety-severity scenarios. A three-way mixed analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted to assess the main and interaction effects of cabin crew gender, passenger gender, and safety incident severity on passenger willingness to comply with cabin crew safety instructions.

Findings indicated, firstly, that female passengers reported greater willingness to comply than male passengers; the main effect of passenger gender significantly influenced passenger willingness to comply with cabin crew safety instructions (F(1,337) = 4.55, p = 0.034, partial eta squared = 0.013). Secondly, the lowest safety incident severity produced greater willingness to comply than the other severities; the main effect of safety incident severity had the largest observed effect on passenger willingness to comply with cabin crew safety instructions (F(2.68, 903.92) = 18.46, p < .001, partial eta squared = 0.052). Thirdly, at the lowest, medium-low, and highest severity levels female passengers reported greater willingness to comply than male passengers. No difference emerged for the medium-high severity level: while waiting for the lavatory scenario instructed to comply with fasten seatbelt sign. There was a statistically significant twoway interaction between safety incident severity and passenger gender (F(2.68, 903.92) = 3.792, p = .013, partial eta squared = 0.011). There was a statistically significant two-way interaction between safety incident severity and cabin crew gender (F(2.68, 903.92) = 2.952, p = .037, partial eta squared = 0.009). The main effect of cabin crew gender did not significantly influence willingness to comply (F(1,337) = 0.355, p = 0.551, partial eta squared = 0.001).

Mediation analyses using Hayes' PROCESS Model 4 revealed perceived cabin crew legitimacy (mobile scenario (b = .424, p < .001) - lavatory scenario (b = .286, p = .030) - emergency scenario (b = .289, p = .039)) and perceived cabin crew effectiveness (mobile scenario (b = .317, p < .001) - overhead stowage compartment scenario (b = .346, p = .001) - emergency scenario (b = .269, p = .023)) emerged as predictors of passenger compliance with cabin crew instructions in certain scenarios; neither mediated the relationship between cabin crew gender and compliance. Prediction and significant indirect effect was observed through affect on willingness to comply with cabin crew instructions regarding overhead stowage compartment usage (Effect = .014, 95% CI [.0001, .0487]) and lavatory use (Effect = .018, 95% CI [.0001, .0519]); however, this indirect effect is small and inconsistent across scenarios.

This study contributes to the literature by extending social role theory research into a regulated, federally mandated aviation context, and highlighting the importance of evaluating how passenger perception of cabin crew and the context of safety incident severity can influence passenger willingness to comply with cabin crew safety instructions. On a practical level, the counterintuitive inverse relationship observed between safety incident severity and passenger willingness to comply represents a critical area for aviation industry stakeholders, including airlines, associations such as IATA, and regulatory bodies such as ICAO requiring further investigation. The finding that perceived legitimacy, perceived effectiveness, and affect are predictors of passenger willingness to comply with cabin crew safety instructions provides a useful conceptual framework for evaluating in-flight interactions between cabin crew and passengers, and also critiquing how airlines represent their cabin crew in marketing media as a safety professional role or a service role. Exploring ways to support cabin crew in operating firmly within their safety mandate, while navigating customer-service expectations, remains a valuable avenue for continuously optimizing safety culture on board commercial flights.

Share

COinS